Court Confirms Minimum Income Requirement for Dependents of Permanent Residents
February 22, 2017
Country / Territory
United Kingdom
The Supreme Court ruled today that the minimum income requirement (MIR) of GBP 18,600 per year introduced in July 2012 for non-European Economic Area nationals seeking leave to enter or remain in the United Kingdomas dependants of British citizens and settled persons is lawful, but that the Immigration Rules do not take into account the best interests of children. This means that going forward, immigration decisions can continue to be based on whether dependants of British citizens and settled persons have met the MIR, although the Immigration Rules will have to be reconsidered as they affect children.
Background
In the case, several appellants appealed a lower tribunal’s decision that disallowed their stay in the United Kingdom, in part due to the fact that they did not meet the MIR. Several appellants with children argued that the lower tribunal's decision did not consider the best interests of the child, which should be the primary factor in an immigration decision that would separate a family.
Income Threshold
The Court explained in its decision that the income threshold was rationally connected to the aim of ensuring that a family does not require welfare benefits in the United Kingdom and has sufficient resources in the United Kingdom. The court regarded such considerations as reasonable in balance with other factors.
Best Interests of Children
However, the Court held that the Immigration Rules as they stand did not take into account the best interests of the child as the primary consideration in the decision regarding whether to separate the family, and that the Rules must therefore be amended in line with established principles.
Alternative Sources of Funding
The Supreme Court also considered whether prospective earnings of the foreign spouse or third party contributions could be taken into account in such cases. While the Court accepted that the current requirements were lawful, it found that such a narrow approach should be revised.
What This Means for Employers and Foreign Nationals
Following this ruling, the MIR will continue to apply.
Upon review of the Rules as ordered by the Court, the Home Office is unlikely to restrict the sources of funding that can be considered in determining whether an applicant meets the MIR. The Rules, however, may be broadened to protect the best interests of the child and to allow applicants to rely on more evidence to demonstrate the MIR is met.
Fragomen will report on the developments of the Rules changes as more information becomes available.
This alert is for informational purposes only. If you have any questions, please contact the global immigration professional with whom you work at Fragomen or send an email to [email protected].
Country / Territory
Explore more at Fragomen
Media mentions
O Diretor de Imigração, Diogo Kloper, compartilha quais indústrias estão recrutando talentos estrangeiros no Brasil.
Blog post
Partner Rahul Soni and Senior Associate Xiaodan (Susan) Song help international commercial enterprise investors make informed decisions by explaining the differences between EB-5 rural projects and high unemployment projects.
Video
Immigration Consultant Azela Hadia discusses how those planning to attend the 2024 Olympics and Paralympics Games in Paris can prepare for their trip from an immigration perspective.
Blog post
This blog provides an overview of immigration programs and relief options by USCIS for Venezuelan nationals amidst the political and economic crisis in Venezuela.
Media mentions
Partner Ángel Bello Cortés shares why Ireland needs a standardised visa system that’s faster and more consistent.
Blog post
This blog discusses Australia's Resident Return visa and its associated "compelling reasons" criteria.
Blog post
Senior Associate Sarah Melnick discusses the available immigration options for individuals not selected in this year's H-1B Cap Lottery.
Media mentions
O Diretor de Imigração, Diogo Kloper, compartilha dados recentes sobre o aumento de vistos de trabalho para profissionais da produção de proteína halal.
Fragomen news
Silicon Valley Managing Partner Kristi Nevarez is recognized as an honoree in the Silicon Valley Business Journal's 2024 Latinx Business Leadership Awards.
Blog post
This blog discusses the complexities individuals face when navigating international travel while awaiting their residence permit in France.
Media mentions
Director Kathleen O’Donnell and Apprentice Immigration Paralegal Grace Harby share insights on the impact of the UK's five-point plan on Northern employers.
Media mentions
Partner Patrick Shen shares what HR professionals should be aware of to avoid discrimination with Form I-9.
Media mentions
O Diretor de Imigração, Diogo Kloper, compartilha quais indústrias estão recrutando talentos estrangeiros no Brasil.
Blog post
Partner Rahul Soni and Senior Associate Xiaodan (Susan) Song help international commercial enterprise investors make informed decisions by explaining the differences between EB-5 rural projects and high unemployment projects.
Video
Immigration Consultant Azela Hadia discusses how those planning to attend the 2024 Olympics and Paralympics Games in Paris can prepare for their trip from an immigration perspective.
Blog post
This blog provides an overview of immigration programs and relief options by USCIS for Venezuelan nationals amidst the political and economic crisis in Venezuela.
Media mentions
Partner Ángel Bello Cortés shares why Ireland needs a standardised visa system that’s faster and more consistent.
Blog post
This blog discusses Australia's Resident Return visa and its associated "compelling reasons" criteria.
Blog post
Senior Associate Sarah Melnick discusses the available immigration options for individuals not selected in this year's H-1B Cap Lottery.
Media mentions
O Diretor de Imigração, Diogo Kloper, compartilha dados recentes sobre o aumento de vistos de trabalho para profissionais da produção de proteína halal.
Fragomen news
Silicon Valley Managing Partner Kristi Nevarez is recognized as an honoree in the Silicon Valley Business Journal's 2024 Latinx Business Leadership Awards.
Blog post
This blog discusses the complexities individuals face when navigating international travel while awaiting their residence permit in France.
Media mentions
Director Kathleen O’Donnell and Apprentice Immigration Paralegal Grace Harby share insights on the impact of the UK's five-point plan on Northern employers.
Media mentions
Partner Patrick Shen shares what HR professionals should be aware of to avoid discrimination with Form I-9.