USCIS Expected to Re-Implement the Public Charge Rule Soon, After Federal Appeals Court Stays Lower Court Injunction
September 14, 2020

At a Glance
- The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit ruled late Friday that a lower court did not have the authority to enjoin the Department of Homeland Security from enforcing its public charge regulation during the COVID-19 national emergency, pursuant to a recent Supreme Court decision.
- Though lawsuits against the DHS public charge rule are ongoing, the Supreme Court ruled that DHS may enforce the rule throughout the United States while those cases continue.
- USCIS is soon expected to resume requiring applicants for adjustment of status and nonimmigrant extensions and changes of status to comply with the regulation.
The issue
Following a recent Supreme Court decision, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit ruled that a federal district court did not have the authority to enjoin the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) from requiring applicants for adjustment of status and changes or extensions of nonimmigrant status to comply with 2019 public charge regulations. The case is New York et al. v. Department of Homeland Security.
The decision is the latest in a string of rulings concerning the public charge regulation. Most recently, on July 29, a New York federal district court barred DHS from enforcing the regulation during the COVID-19 national emergency; days later, the Second Circuit restricted the injunction to Connecticut, New York, and Vermont while the lawsuit continues. Shortly thereafter, DHS asked the Second Circuit to stay that limited injunction, arguing that the Supreme Court has allowed the agency to enforce the rule while challenges to it are litigated. Friday’s ruling is the result of that request.
The DHS public charge regulation is being challenged in several federal lawsuits; those lawsuits continue. Separately, an injunction that prohibits the State Department from enforcing its separate public charge regulation for foreign nationals applying for visas outside of the United States remains in place.
What this means for employers and foreign nationals
USCIS is expected to issue instructions requiring applicants and petitioners to comply with the public charge regulation when filing Form I-485 applications for adjustment of status and nonimmigrant applications to change or extend nonimmigrant status on Forms I-129 and I-539/I-539A. The agency is expected to resume requiring adjustment applicants to submit detailed personal and financial information on Form I-944, the declaration of self-sufficiency, unless otherwise exempt. The forthcoming USCIS instructions are also expected to provide information on public charge compliance for cases that were filed while the regulation was enjoined.
Fragomen is closely monitoring the status of the DHS public charge rule and will issue further client alerts as USCIS issues implementation instructions.
This alert is for informational purposes only. If you have any questions, please contact the immigration professional with whom you work at Fragomen.
Explore more at Fragomen
Fragomen on immigration
Partner K. Edward Raleigh analyzes how post‑midterm US business immigration will shift toward heightened enforcement, worker‑protection scrutiny and cross‑agency oversight, urging employers to align hiring practices, sponsorship decisions and documentation with consistent, defensible workforce strategies.
Media mentions
Awards
Fragomen is named “Law Firm of the Year” for Immigration Law by Best Law Firms™ - Australia and receives National and Regional Tier 1 rankings in Immigration Law.
Media mentions
Partner Parisa Karaahmet discusses the broad application of a USCIS memo to adjustment of status applicants and notes that H- and L-visa holders may have a somewhat easier burden in demonstrating factors that support favorable discretion.
Article
Senior Manager Alice Spaull and Associate Stephanie Fitton examine the evolving UK immigration and Electronic Travel Authorisation (ETA) requirements for athletes, their support teams and associated guests attending the Commonwealth Games 2026, highlighting key compliance risks and the importance of early travel planning.
Media mentions
Media mentions
Partner K. Edward Raleigh discusses a recent USCIS memo that appears to signal greater caution in how adjudicators assess adjustment of status cases rather than establishing a new legal standard.
Video
Senior Manager Sumejja Handzo outlines Germany’s health insurance requirements for visas and residence permits, including coverage options, documentation considerations and key compliance requirements for foreign nationals relocating to Germany.
Media mentions
Partner Daniel Schwarz highlights how US visa appointment backlogs and limited availability for B visas are shaping international travel planning for the upcoming World Cup.
Article
Knowledge Management Manager Annabelle Duchêne explores how Europe’s prolonged reliance on Temporary Protection Status has created legal and workforce uncertainty and why clear, structured exit pathways are now essential for employers and displaced individuals alike.
Article
Destination Services Director Christine Sperr examines how Saudi Arabia’s evolving Premium Residency framework and newly expanded foreign property ownership rules are reshaping the Kingdom’s appeal for internationally mobile professionals, global employers and institutional investors.
Fragomen on immigration
Partner K. Edward Raleigh analyzes how post‑midterm US business immigration will shift toward heightened enforcement, worker‑protection scrutiny and cross‑agency oversight, urging employers to align hiring practices, sponsorship decisions and documentation with consistent, defensible workforce strategies.
Media mentions
Awards
Fragomen is named “Law Firm of the Year” for Immigration Law by Best Law Firms™ - Australia and receives National and Regional Tier 1 rankings in Immigration Law.
Media mentions
Partner Parisa Karaahmet discusses the broad application of a USCIS memo to adjustment of status applicants and notes that H- and L-visa holders may have a somewhat easier burden in demonstrating factors that support favorable discretion.
Article
Senior Manager Alice Spaull and Associate Stephanie Fitton examine the evolving UK immigration and Electronic Travel Authorisation (ETA) requirements for athletes, their support teams and associated guests attending the Commonwealth Games 2026, highlighting key compliance risks and the importance of early travel planning.
Media mentions
Media mentions
Partner K. Edward Raleigh discusses a recent USCIS memo that appears to signal greater caution in how adjudicators assess adjustment of status cases rather than establishing a new legal standard.
Video
Senior Manager Sumejja Handzo outlines Germany’s health insurance requirements for visas and residence permits, including coverage options, documentation considerations and key compliance requirements for foreign nationals relocating to Germany.
Media mentions
Partner Daniel Schwarz highlights how US visa appointment backlogs and limited availability for B visas are shaping international travel planning for the upcoming World Cup.
Article
Knowledge Management Manager Annabelle Duchêne explores how Europe’s prolonged reliance on Temporary Protection Status has created legal and workforce uncertainty and why clear, structured exit pathways are now essential for employers and displaced individuals alike.
Article
Destination Services Director Christine Sperr examines how Saudi Arabia’s evolving Premium Residency framework and newly expanded foreign property ownership rules are reshaping the Kingdom’s appeal for internationally mobile professionals, global employers and institutional investors.

