The Impact of Temporary Migration to Australia: Fragomen Provides Evidence to the Senate Select Committee on Temporary Migration
September 18, 2020

Country / Territory
By: Teresa Liu
On 5 December 2019, the Australian Senate resolved to establish a Select Committee on Temporary Migration to inquire into—and report on—the impact temporary migration has on the Australian economy, wages and jobs, social cohesion, and workplace rights and conditions. It focused particularly on government policy settings, policy responses to challenges posed by temporary migration, the benefits of temporary to permanent migration and exploitation of foreign workers.
Fragomen Australia made a submission to the Select Committee at the start of the pandemic in March, and Justin Gibbs and I appeared by invitation of the Select Committee to give evidence through a public hearing on 17 September.
While the interest of the Select Committee related to issues predominantly regarding the risks of worker exploitation in certain sectors, as well as issues of social cohesion involving temporary foreign visa holders, we were able to put forward the following opinions which, based on the recent Client Survey and Report, remain valid during the pandemic and the recovery phase.
- Demand continues for skilled, internationally experienced individuals to fill roles critical to the operations of business and industries that cannot be met by the Australian labour market.
- It is critical that the Australian and New Zealand Standard Classification of Occupations (ANZSCO) system is revisited and updated to represent more relevant occupations for today’s industry. Alternately, another mechanism to ensure that the Department is considering roles/occupations and future roles/occupations in real-time could be implemented. The agenda of the National Skills Commission is a good start toward this goal.
- We strongly emphasised the importance of a skilled temporary program to fill short-term skills gaps, including gaps that arise because of the fast-changing pace of digitalisation and other temporary niche skill sets, but also to support an internationally competitive Australia.
- We stressed the importance of a distinct and separate visa for intra-company transfers, as opposed to the current system that incorporates these transfers under the TSS (Subclass 482) visa, albeit with some concessions.
- We expressed support for simpler and more direct pathways to permanent migration. Our opinion is that the decoupling of the temporary and permanent programs could be a barrier to successful migration outcomes.
Fragomen continues to hear and represent the interests of our clients. Please take a moment to read the findings from our recent Government Relations Report, Immigration and Australia’s Road to Recovery Post-Pandemic.
Additionally, if you have questions regarding any of the issues discussed above, please reach out to me, Teresa Liu, Managing Partner of Australia and New Zealand, at [email protected], or Justin Gibbs, our Director of Government Relations, APAC, at [email protected].
This blog was released on 11 September, and due to the circumstances, there are frequent changes. To keep current with all the latest updates on global immigration, please subscribe to our alerts.
Country / Territory
Explore more at Fragomen
Media mentions
Practice Leader Colm Collins explains how Ireland's employment permit updates can help employers address workforce shortages while strengthening the country's ability to attract global talent.
Blog post
Senior Associate Arta Djahanschiri and Associate Iris Barthel discuss how EU-Turkey Association Law, including Association Council Decision No. 1/80, can provide Turkish employees and their family members in Germany with residence and labor market rights that may extend beyond protections available under the German Residence Act.

Media mentions
Partner Marius Tollenaere and Associate Jamela Sharrock examine how employers in Germany can strengthen immigration compliance by embedding it into every stage of the employment lifecycle.
Podcast
In this episode of The Immigration Conversation, Partner Chad Blocker, Senior Counsel Mitchell Wexler and Associate Alex Kim discuss what prospective EB-5 applicants should know now, including source-of-funds documentation, project selection, concurrent filing, retrogression and upcoming program deadlines.
Blog post
In this blog, Partner Jo Antoons and Senior Manager Marina Ocariz discuss the EU’s provisional agreement on revised social security coordination rules and what employers should know about the expected changes to A1 certificate requirements, posted worker rules and short-term cross-border work compliance.
Blog post
In this blog, Partner Rahul Soni explains the EB-5 grandfathering provisions under the EB-5 Reform and Integrity Act of 2022 and why prospective investors should consider filing before the September 30, 2026 deadline to help preserve statutory protections and reduce exposure to future program uncertainty.
Video
In this video, Practice Leader Kate Praphakornphiphat explains the key requirements, documents, fees and processing time for a Thailand tourist visa, as well as stay duration and extension options for short-term travel.
Fragomen news
Fragomen and Talent Beyond Boundaries announce that they will jointly serve as co-chairs of the Global Task Force on Refugee Labour Mobility for a two-year term beginning in June 2026.
Blog post
In this blog, Manager Gillian Gibbons and Immigration Consultants Gemma Oliver and Larna Kate Hadfield examine how Barnsley’s designation as the UK’s first government-backed Tech Town reflects wider AI and digital growth across the North of England, and why immigration strategy will be critical for employers seeking to access the global talent needed to support regional innovation.
Media mentions
In this Hong Kong Business article, Managing Director Magdalene Tennant discusses Hong Kong’s recent decision to allow employment and dependent visa renewal applications to be filed up to three months before expiry, a change intended to reduce the risk of work disruptions and provide employers with greater flexibility in managing foreign talent.
Media mentions
In this article published by Professional Engineering, Senior Manager Nadine Barnole examines how UK engineering employers can continue to access international talent amid growing skills shortages and a rapidly evolving immigration landscape.
Media mentions
In this Times Brasil CNBC Real Tech interview, Partner Diana Quintas discusses Brazil’s recent visa exemption for Chinese nationals, what it signals for Brazil-China mobility and how technology is helping support more efficient cross-border movement.
Media mentions
Practice Leader Colm Collins explains how Ireland's employment permit updates can help employers address workforce shortages while strengthening the country's ability to attract global talent.
Blog post
Senior Associate Arta Djahanschiri and Associate Iris Barthel discuss how EU-Turkey Association Law, including Association Council Decision No. 1/80, can provide Turkish employees and their family members in Germany with residence and labor market rights that may extend beyond protections available under the German Residence Act.

Media mentions
Partner Marius Tollenaere and Associate Jamela Sharrock examine how employers in Germany can strengthen immigration compliance by embedding it into every stage of the employment lifecycle.
Podcast
In this episode of The Immigration Conversation, Partner Chad Blocker, Senior Counsel Mitchell Wexler and Associate Alex Kim discuss what prospective EB-5 applicants should know now, including source-of-funds documentation, project selection, concurrent filing, retrogression and upcoming program deadlines.
Blog post
In this blog, Partner Jo Antoons and Senior Manager Marina Ocariz discuss the EU’s provisional agreement on revised social security coordination rules and what employers should know about the expected changes to A1 certificate requirements, posted worker rules and short-term cross-border work compliance.
Blog post
In this blog, Partner Rahul Soni explains the EB-5 grandfathering provisions under the EB-5 Reform and Integrity Act of 2022 and why prospective investors should consider filing before the September 30, 2026 deadline to help preserve statutory protections and reduce exposure to future program uncertainty.
Video
In this video, Practice Leader Kate Praphakornphiphat explains the key requirements, documents, fees and processing time for a Thailand tourist visa, as well as stay duration and extension options for short-term travel.
Fragomen news
Fragomen and Talent Beyond Boundaries announce that they will jointly serve as co-chairs of the Global Task Force on Refugee Labour Mobility for a two-year term beginning in June 2026.
Blog post
In this blog, Manager Gillian Gibbons and Immigration Consultants Gemma Oliver and Larna Kate Hadfield examine how Barnsley’s designation as the UK’s first government-backed Tech Town reflects wider AI and digital growth across the North of England, and why immigration strategy will be critical for employers seeking to access the global talent needed to support regional innovation.
Media mentions
In this Hong Kong Business article, Managing Director Magdalene Tennant discusses Hong Kong’s recent decision to allow employment and dependent visa renewal applications to be filed up to three months before expiry, a change intended to reduce the risk of work disruptions and provide employers with greater flexibility in managing foreign talent.
Media mentions
In this article published by Professional Engineering, Senior Manager Nadine Barnole examines how UK engineering employers can continue to access international talent amid growing skills shortages and a rapidly evolving immigration landscape.
Media mentions
In this Times Brasil CNBC Real Tech interview, Partner Diana Quintas discusses Brazil’s recent visa exemption for Chinese nationals, what it signals for Brazil-China mobility and how technology is helping support more efficient cross-border movement.
