Important Updates
Important Updates
October 2, 2025 | United KingdomConstruction Management: Immigration Compliance: Is Your Firm Violating Visa Rules?
October 3, 2025 | KazakhstanKazakhstan: New Work Permit Process Rules, Including Labor Market Test and New Online Portal
October 3, 2025 | United StatesThe American Lawyer: Proposed H-1B Changes Make Foreign Lawyers More Expensive, but Also More Accessible
October 2, 2025 | Japan, United States 2025年9月 アメリカ移民法ダイジェスト
October 2, 2025 | United StatesComputer Weekly: How UK Immigration Must Evolve to Attract the Best Global Talent
October 2, 2025 | United KingdomConstruction Management: Immigration Compliance: Is Your Firm Violating Visa Rules?
October 3, 2025 | KazakhstanKazakhstan: New Work Permit Process Rules, Including Labor Market Test and New Online Portal
October 3, 2025 | United StatesThe American Lawyer: Proposed H-1B Changes Make Foreign Lawyers More Expensive, but Also More Accessible
October 2, 2025 | Japan, United States 2025年9月 アメリカ移民法ダイジェスト
October 2, 2025 | United StatesComputer Weekly: How UK Immigration Must Evolve to Attract the Best Global Talent
October 2, 2025 | United KingdomConstruction Management: Immigration Compliance: Is Your Firm Violating Visa Rules?
Subscribe
Fragomen.com home
Select Language
  • English
  • French
  • French - Canadian
  • German

Select Language

  • English
  • French
  • French - Canadian
  • German
ContactCareersMediaClient Portal
Search Fragomen.com
  • Our Services
    For EmployersFor IndividualsBy IndustryCase Studies
  • Our Tech & Innovation
  • Our People
  • Our Insights
    Worldwide Immigration Trends ReportsMagellan SeriesImmigration AlertsEventsMedia MentionsFragomen NewsBlogsPodcasts & Videos
  • Spotlights
    Navigating Immigration Under the Second Trump AdministrationTravel & Mobility Considerations: Situation in the Middle EastImmigration Matters: Your U.S. Compliance RoadmapCenter for Strategy and Applied InsightsVietnamese ImmigrationView More
  • About Us
    About FragomenOfficesResponsible Business PracticesFirm GovernanceRecognition

Our Services

  • For Employers
  • For Individuals
  • By Industry
  • Case Studies

Our Tech & Innovation

  • Our Approach

Our People

  • Overview / Directory

Our Insights

  • Worldwide Immigration Trends Reports
  • Magellan Series
  • Immigration Alerts
  • Events
  • Media Mentions
  • Fragomen News
  • Blogs
  • Podcasts & Videos

Spotlights

  • Navigating Immigration Under the Second Trump Administration
  • Travel & Mobility Considerations: Situation in the Middle East
  • Immigration Matters: Your U.S. Compliance Roadmap
  • Center for Strategy and Applied Insights
  • Vietnamese Immigration
  • View More

About Us

  • About Fragomen
  • Offices
  • Responsible Business Practices
  • Firm Governance
  • Recognition
Select Language
  • English
  • French
  • French - Canadian
  • German

Select Language

  • English
  • French
  • French - Canadian
  • German
ContactCareersMediaClient Portal
  • Insights

EU Court of Justice Gives Broad Interpretation of the “non-replacement condition” for Posted Workers

September 7, 2018

business travel

Countries / Territories

  • 🌐

Related contacts

Wim Cocquyt

Wim Cocquyt

Client Engagement Director Europe

Brussels (Benelux), Belgium

Email

[email protected]

T:+32 (0)2 250 4875

Related offices

  • Brussels (Benelux)
  • Dublin
  • Frankfurt
  • London
  • Paris

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Related contacts

Wim Cocquyt

Wim Cocquyt

Client Engagement Director Europe

Brussels (Benelux), Belgium

Email

[email protected]

T:+32 (0)2 250 4875

Related offices

  • Brussels (Benelux)
  • Dublin
  • Frankfurt
  • London
  • Paris

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Related contacts

Wim Cocquyt

Wim Cocquyt

Client Engagement Director Europe

Brussels (Benelux), Belgium

Email

[email protected]

T:+32 (0)2 250 4875

Related offices

  • Brussels (Benelux)
  • Dublin
  • Frankfurt
  • London
  • Paris

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

By: Wim Cocquyt

According to consistent case-law of the Court of Justice of the European Union (‘CJEU’ or ‘the Court’), confirmed in the current European Regulations, a Certificate of Coverage (CoC, commonly known before as E101, and now as A1 certificate) should be considered binding, and therefore in principle it does not allow the institutions of the host country to investigate on its validity.

However, in the recent Altun-judgment of 6 February 2018 (C-359/16), the Court has for the first time allowed an exception to this consolidated approach: a court of the host country may disregard an E101 (or A1) certificate, formally issued in accordance with the provisions of the EU Regulations by the competent institution of the home country, if that court finds that the certificate was obtained or invoked fraudulently.

Due to the changing legal landscape, especially in Europe, the application for a CoC has become fundamental, not only for showing compliance with social security obligations during the temporary secondment period, but also for securing work permits and for guaranteeing compliance with posted worker notification requirements from day 1.

The CJEU Judgment

In its recent judgement of 6 September 2018 (Alpenrind C-527/16), the Court replied to a request for preliminary ruling from an Austrian Upper Administrative court regarding one of the formal conditions for a valid posting under the EU Regulations, i.e. the fact that an employee cannot be sent to replace another employee (the so-called ‘non-replacement condition’). 

To underline the importance of the present judgment, not less than eight Member States as well as the European Commission have submitted their observations to the Court in this respect.

The Court re-confirms, as a starting point, the binding nature of the E101 or A1 certificate so long as the certificate has not been withdrawn or invalidated by the issuing Member State, and even if it was issued with retro-active effect (after the employee concerned was made subject to the social security system of the host Member State), except in the case of fraud or abuse of rights. Moreover, the Court recalls the procedure to be followed if the host country authorities have doubts about the accuracy of the facts on the basis of which the CoC has been issued by the home country authorities. 

But what is important about this judgement is that the Court has ruled that the non-replacement condition for a genuine posting of an employee is an objective criterion, in the sense that one merely has to consider whether there is a recurrent use of posted workers to fill the same role, or do the same job activity at the premises of the (same) host country entity. This is regardless of whether the replacement worker is posted by a different employer, located in the same Member State, and irrespectively whether there are staffing or organisational links between the employers concerned.

Interestingly, the Advocate General Saug­mands­gaard Øe had come to a completely different conclusion in his opinion earlier this year (See one of our previous blogs - here), where he underlined the need for the intentional element in order not to allow maintenance of the Home country social security coverage for the posted worker: i.e., the wish of the linked employers to bypass the non-replacement condition with the postings.

It is worthwhile to mention that an amendment proposed in the new draft EU Regulation specifically aims at making the non-replacement condition more flexible, at least for postings up to 24 months.  

How We Can Help

The present ruling can be seen as another attempt to fight ‘social dumping’ and the willingness to introduce stricter rules with regard to A1 forms. It will most likely give rise to more careful investigation activities from the host country authorities in case of audits, whereas until now the non-replacement condition was interpreted and applied in a more relaxed manner.

Fragomen can assist your company with ensuring that A1 certificates are requested in accordance with the requirements of the EU Regulations, in line with the CJEU decisions, and make sure your company is compliant in both immigration and social security, from day one.

For any social security related question, please contact us at [email protected]

Countries / Territories

  • 🌐

Related contacts

Wim Cocquyt

Wim Cocquyt

Client Engagement Director Europe

Brussels (Benelux), Belgium

Email

[email protected]

T:+32 (0)2 250 4875

Related offices

  • Brussels (Benelux)
  • Dublin
  • Frankfurt
  • London
  • Paris

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Related contacts

Wim Cocquyt

Wim Cocquyt

Client Engagement Director Europe

Brussels (Benelux), Belgium

Email

[email protected]

T:+32 (0)2 250 4875

Related offices

  • Brussels (Benelux)
  • Dublin
  • Frankfurt
  • London
  • Paris

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Related contacts

Wim Cocquyt

Wim Cocquyt

Client Engagement Director Europe

Brussels (Benelux), Belgium

Email

[email protected]

T:+32 (0)2 250 4875

Related offices

  • Brussels (Benelux)
  • Dublin
  • Frankfurt
  • London
  • Paris

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Explore more at Fragomen

Media mentions

The American Lawyer: Proposed H-1B Changes Make Foreign Lawyers More Expensive, but Also More Accessible

Partner Bo Cooper outlines how the proposed H-1B changes could affect Big Law hiring for foreign lawyers.

Learn more

Fragomen news

2025年9月 アメリカ移民法ダイジェストLearn more

Media mentions

Computer Weekly: How UK Immigration Must Evolve to Attract the Best Global Talent

Senior Manager Kinka Tonchev highlights how UK immigration must adapt to attract, retain and support the world’s top talent.

Learn more

Media mentions

Construction Management: Immigration Compliance: Is Your Firm Violating Visa Rules?

Manager Kirsty Moore and Trainee Solicitor Amanda Ong highlight rising UK construction sponsor licence risks and how businesses can stay compliant.

Learn more

Awards

Partner Abeer Al Husseini Recognised at the Gulf Business Awards 2025

Partner Abeer Al Husseini is recognised on the shortlist for "Women Leader of the Year" at the Gulf Business Awards 2025.

Learn more

Media mentions

The Washington Post: How Companies Might Avoid Trump’s New $100K Visa

Co-Chair Enrique Gonzalez highlights approaches for companies navigating changes to the H-1B visa process.

Learn more

Video

How to Get Your French Work Visa After Graduation: Job Seeker / Company Creation Permit

Learn how international graduates can stay in France for one year to find work or start a business. Discover eligibility requirements, application steps and transition options for the Job Seeker/New Business Creator permit. 

Learn more

Awards

Partner Priscilla Muhlenkamp Named 2025 National Law Journal Awards Finalist for "DC Managing Partner of the Year"

Partner Priscilla Muhlenkamp is a finalist for the 2025 National Law Journal Awards category, "DC Managing Partner of the Year."

Learn more

Media mentions

Post Bulletin: Trump’s New $100K Fee on Certain Work Visas Could Impact Rochester’s Medical Staff

Partner Bo Cooper highlights that new $100K H-1B fees could affect US employers, with possible exemptions for critical roles.

Learn more

Media mentions

The Caterer: Businesses Need to Be Ready for Government Crackdown on Sponsor Licences

Partner Louise Senior highlights the impact of record-breaking UK sponsor licence revocations and the steps hospitality businesses can take to manage compliance.

Learn more

Media mentions

Folha de São Paulo: Taxa de US$ 100 mil para visto dos EUA muda planosde brasileiros; veja opções

Partner Bo Cooper explores the impact of H-1B visa changes on companies and their talent strategies.

Learn more

Media mentions

Global Mobility Lawyer: Lawyers Try to Make Sense of Trump’s Confusing H-1B Fee Hike

Partner Bo Cooper explains that while new H-1B fees affect future petitions, US opportunities for international talent remain highly valued.

Learn more

Media mentions

The American Lawyer: Proposed H-1B Changes Make Foreign Lawyers More Expensive, but Also More Accessible

Partner Bo Cooper outlines how the proposed H-1B changes could affect Big Law hiring for foreign lawyers.

Learn more

Fragomen news

2025年9月 アメリカ移民法ダイジェストLearn more

Media mentions

Computer Weekly: How UK Immigration Must Evolve to Attract the Best Global Talent

Senior Manager Kinka Tonchev highlights how UK immigration must adapt to attract, retain and support the world’s top talent.

Learn more

Media mentions

Construction Management: Immigration Compliance: Is Your Firm Violating Visa Rules?

Manager Kirsty Moore and Trainee Solicitor Amanda Ong highlight rising UK construction sponsor licence risks and how businesses can stay compliant.

Learn more

Awards

Partner Abeer Al Husseini Recognised at the Gulf Business Awards 2025

Partner Abeer Al Husseini is recognised on the shortlist for "Women Leader of the Year" at the Gulf Business Awards 2025.

Learn more

Media mentions

The Washington Post: How Companies Might Avoid Trump’s New $100K Visa

Co-Chair Enrique Gonzalez highlights approaches for companies navigating changes to the H-1B visa process.

Learn more

Video

How to Get Your French Work Visa After Graduation: Job Seeker / Company Creation Permit

Learn how international graduates can stay in France for one year to find work or start a business. Discover eligibility requirements, application steps and transition options for the Job Seeker/New Business Creator permit. 

Learn more

Awards

Partner Priscilla Muhlenkamp Named 2025 National Law Journal Awards Finalist for "DC Managing Partner of the Year"

Partner Priscilla Muhlenkamp is a finalist for the 2025 National Law Journal Awards category, "DC Managing Partner of the Year."

Learn more

Media mentions

Post Bulletin: Trump’s New $100K Fee on Certain Work Visas Could Impact Rochester’s Medical Staff

Partner Bo Cooper highlights that new $100K H-1B fees could affect US employers, with possible exemptions for critical roles.

Learn more

Media mentions

The Caterer: Businesses Need to Be Ready for Government Crackdown on Sponsor Licences

Partner Louise Senior highlights the impact of record-breaking UK sponsor licence revocations and the steps hospitality businesses can take to manage compliance.

Learn more

Media mentions

Folha de São Paulo: Taxa de US$ 100 mil para visto dos EUA muda planosde brasileiros; veja opções

Partner Bo Cooper explores the impact of H-1B visa changes on companies and their talent strategies.

Learn more

Media mentions

Global Mobility Lawyer: Lawyers Try to Make Sense of Trump’s Confusing H-1B Fee Hike

Partner Bo Cooper explains that while new H-1B fees affect future petitions, US opportunities for international talent remain highly valued.

Learn more

Stay in touch

Subscribe to receive our latest immigration alerts

Subscribe

Our firm

  • About
  • Careers
  • Firm Governance
  • Media Inquiries
  • Recognition

Information

  • Attorney Advertising
  • Legal Notices
  • Privacy Policies
  • UK Regulatory Requirements

Our firm

  • About
  • Careers
  • Firm Governance
  • Media Inquiries
  • Recognition

Information

  • Attorney Advertising
  • Legal Notices
  • Privacy Policies
  • UK Regulatory Requirements

Have a question?

Contact Us
  • LinkedIn
  • Youtube
  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • Twitter

© 2025 Fragomen, Del Rey, Bernsen & Loewy, LLP, Fragomen Global LLP and affiliates. All Rights Reserved.

Please note that the content made available on this site is not intended for visitors / customers located in the province of Quebec, and the information provided is not applicable to the Quebec market. To access relevant information that applies to the Quebec market, please click here.