• Insights

A1 Certificate Fraud: Key Takeaways from the 2025 ECJ Decision

May 28, 2025

A1 Certificate Fraud: Key Takeaways from the 2025 ECJ Decision

Countries / Territories

  • BelgiumBelgium
  • European UnionEuropean Union

Related offices

  • Brussels

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Related offices

  • Brussels

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Related offices

  • Brussels

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

By: Marina Ocariz

In a landmark judgement issued on January 23, 2025 (Case C-421/23), the European Court of Justice (ECJ) provided important clarifications on the application of EU social security regulations concerning posted workers and the authenticity of A1 certificates.

While the judgment was delivered earlier this year, its practical implications are coming into sharper focus now as national authorities begin to operationalise the ECJ's guidance—particularly in the context of increasing cross-border inspections and enforcement activity. The case offers timely and important guidance on the obligations of national authorities and courts in the presence of fraudulent A1 certificates.

This blog outlines the main takeaways from the decision and how the ECJ ruling impacts Employers requesting A1 Certificates in the EU.

What is an A1 Certificate and why does it matter?

An A1 Certificate is a document issued by a competent national social security authority that evidences where the employee’s social security contributions are being paid. It applies to posted workers, business travellers, and self-employed workers on temporary assignments and to workers that perform duties in multiple EU countries at the same time.

The A1 Certificate helps ensure legal compliance, avoid double social security payments, and is often required for immigration and posted worker notifications. Failure to secure an A1 Certificate may lead to high fines or delays in work approvals. 

What was the 2025 ECJ case about?

Case C-421/23 originated from criminal proceedings in Belgium against a Portuguese contractor who had employed 650 Portuguese workers on Belgian construction sites between 2012 and 2017. The employees were in possession of A1 certificates that had not been issued by the competent Portuguese social security institution.

As the Belgian social security authorities discovered that the A1 certificates were fraudulent, the Belgian court found the Portuguese employer guilty of fraud in relation to social security contribution payments and the use of false documents. The case was subsequently brought in front of the Court of Appeal, which referred some important questions to the ECJ.

Overview of the ECJ Ruling in Case C-421/23 

The ECJ made three key findings:

      • Regulation 883/2004 on the coordination of social security systems applies even when A1 certificates are found to be fraudulently obtained, because it ensures that employees are subject only to one EU member State’s social security legislation at the time, which prevents legal uncertainty. Consequently, national courts must assess whether the conditions for posting workers from a social security perspective have been met in accordance with the posting provisions of the Regulation.
      • When there is a suspicion of fraud, national authorities of the member States mandatorily must engage in the structured dialogue and conciliation procedure laid down in Regulation 883/2004 before making a unilateral finding of fraud, which re-affirms one of the important principles of social security coordination, i.e. the principle of sincere cooperation between member States.
      • When the issuing social security authority explicitly denies having issued the A1 certificates (or confirms they are invalid), the national courts of the other member State are no longer bound by their contents, without the need for any further administrative consultation.

What this means for businesses operating in multiple EU countries

The ECJ ruling in reference reinforces the importance of A1 certificates in the field of labor migration and intra-EU employee mobility. A1 certificates hold significant legal weight, and host country inspection authorities cannot simply disregard them or impose social security contributions—even in cases where the certificates are suspected or found to be fraudulent.

Importantly, the ruling re-confirms the importance of legal certainty and ‘strong’ validity of an A1 by highlighting the mandatory nature of the dialogue and conciliation procedure between national authorities of different Member States. A1 certificates safeguard companies from host country social security claims, and in cases of doubt, host authorities are required to initiate the conciliation procedure with the home Member State before any withdrawal or challenge of the A1 form—ensuring that companies are not exposed to double social security contributions.

This case re-enforces the tendency we have seen over the last years in the increase in inspections across European countries regarding the absence of A1 Certificates for posted workers and it emphasises the importance of compliance with social security obligations when posting employees. To facilitate this enforcement, the EU has now fully implemented systems such as the Electronic Exchange of Social Security Information (EESSI), a digital platform that connects social security institutions across the EU. With this the European Union is trying to streamline the verification process and cooperation among national authorities.

How can Fragomen help?

The Fragomen Social Security team assist clients in managing their A1 certificate applications in line with EU regulations. With a strategic focus on compliance, the team helps ensure that social security, immigration, and posted worker obligations are considered early in the planning process.

Need to know more?

For questions regarding A1 compliance, please contact the Fragomen Social Security team at [email protected].

This blog was published on 28 May 2025, and due to the circumstances, there are frequent changes. To keep up to date with all the latest updates on global immigration, please subscribe to our alerts and follow us on LinkedIn, Twitter, Facebook and Instagram. 

Countries / Territories

  • BelgiumBelgium
  • European UnionEuropean Union

Related offices

  • Brussels

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Related offices

  • Brussels

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Related offices

  • Brussels

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Explore more at Fragomen

Media mentions

Forbes: Immigration Rule Aims To Block Many High-Skilled Green Card Applicants

Partner Kevin Miner discusses the legal concerns surrounding the DOL's proposed PERM rule and its potential impact on employers’ ability to retain talent.

Learn more

Blog post

How to Apply for Costa Rica Permanent Residence

In part two of this series, Immigration Supervisor Michael Salas Guzman explains what applicants and families should expect throughout the permanent residence application process, from preparation and filing through final documentation.

Learn more

Media mentions

Human Resources Director: HR Leaders Must Treat Immigration as Strategy, Not Paperwork

Canada Managing Partner Cosmina Morariu outlines how HR leaders can integrate immigration into workforce planning, strengthen business resilience and better manage global mobility risks.

Learn more

Awards

Partner Lisa Ryan Appointed to University of San Francisco’s Women in Leadership in the Age of AI Advisory Board

Partner Lisa Ryan has been appointed to the Advisory Board for the Women in Leadership in the Age of AI Program at the University of San Francisco School of Management.

Learn more

Blog post

Christmas Travel While Your German Residence Permit Is Pending: Do You Need a Fiktionsbescheinigung?

In a new blog, Senior Associate Ruben Fiedler explains what internationally mobile employees and employers should consider before holiday travel, including the importance of checking the legal basis of an interim permit and requesting the appropriate documentation early.

Learn more

Media mentions

Times of India: US Proposes Sweeping Changes to Green Card Rules, Raises Employer Compliance Burden and Tightens Scrutiny of Layoffs

Senior Counsel Mitch Wexler discusses proposed changes to the PERM program, including extended recruitment periods and additional documentation requirements for employers sponsoring foreign workers for permanent residence.

Learn more

Video

Brazil Statutory Director Visa: Requirements, Investment and Process

In this video, Brazil Managing Partner Diana Quintas explains the statutory director visa, outlining who qualifies, key compliance considerations and what employers and directors should consider when planning appointments or changes to board leadership.

Learn more

Eb-5

Upcoming EB-5 Fee and Investment Increases: What Investors Need to Know

Partner Rahul Soni discusses upcoming increases to EB-5 government filing fees and minimum investment amounts, outlining key deadlines and considerations for prospective investors planning to file under the current requirements.

Learn more

Media mentions

Times Higher Education: UK Student Visa Applications Fall in October

Senior Manager Jonathan Hill discusses factors behind the decline in UK student visa applications, including recruitment restrictions, rising costs and changes to post-study work rights.

Learn more

Fragomen news

Comment on USCIS’s Proposed Rule to Eliminate Deference to Prior ApprovalsLearn more

Fragomen news

Fragomen Appoints Timo Heck as Managing Partner of DACH Region

Fragomen has appointed Timo Heck as Managing Partner of the DACH region, encompassing Germany, Austria and Switzerland.

Learn more

Awards

Fragomen Professionals Recognized in the 2027 Edition of The Best Lawyers in Mexico™

Eight professionals in Fragomen’s Mexico City office have been recognized in the 2027 edition of The Best Lawyers in Mexico™ for Immigration Law.

Learn more

Media mentions

Forbes: Immigration Rule Aims To Block Many High-Skilled Green Card Applicants

Partner Kevin Miner discusses the legal concerns surrounding the DOL's proposed PERM rule and its potential impact on employers’ ability to retain talent.

Learn more

Blog post

How to Apply for Costa Rica Permanent Residence

In part two of this series, Immigration Supervisor Michael Salas Guzman explains what applicants and families should expect throughout the permanent residence application process, from preparation and filing through final documentation.

Learn more

Media mentions

Human Resources Director: HR Leaders Must Treat Immigration as Strategy, Not Paperwork

Canada Managing Partner Cosmina Morariu outlines how HR leaders can integrate immigration into workforce planning, strengthen business resilience and better manage global mobility risks.

Learn more

Awards

Partner Lisa Ryan Appointed to University of San Francisco’s Women in Leadership in the Age of AI Advisory Board

Partner Lisa Ryan has been appointed to the Advisory Board for the Women in Leadership in the Age of AI Program at the University of San Francisco School of Management.

Learn more

Blog post

Christmas Travel While Your German Residence Permit Is Pending: Do You Need a Fiktionsbescheinigung?

In a new blog, Senior Associate Ruben Fiedler explains what internationally mobile employees and employers should consider before holiday travel, including the importance of checking the legal basis of an interim permit and requesting the appropriate documentation early.

Learn more

Media mentions

Times of India: US Proposes Sweeping Changes to Green Card Rules, Raises Employer Compliance Burden and Tightens Scrutiny of Layoffs

Senior Counsel Mitch Wexler discusses proposed changes to the PERM program, including extended recruitment periods and additional documentation requirements for employers sponsoring foreign workers for permanent residence.

Learn more

Video

Brazil Statutory Director Visa: Requirements, Investment and Process

In this video, Brazil Managing Partner Diana Quintas explains the statutory director visa, outlining who qualifies, key compliance considerations and what employers and directors should consider when planning appointments or changes to board leadership.

Learn more

Eb-5

Upcoming EB-5 Fee and Investment Increases: What Investors Need to Know

Partner Rahul Soni discusses upcoming increases to EB-5 government filing fees and minimum investment amounts, outlining key deadlines and considerations for prospective investors planning to file under the current requirements.

Learn more

Media mentions

Times Higher Education: UK Student Visa Applications Fall in October

Senior Manager Jonathan Hill discusses factors behind the decline in UK student visa applications, including recruitment restrictions, rising costs and changes to post-study work rights.

Learn more

Fragomen news

Comment on USCIS’s Proposed Rule to Eliminate Deference to Prior ApprovalsLearn more

Fragomen news

Fragomen Appoints Timo Heck as Managing Partner of DACH Region

Fragomen has appointed Timo Heck as Managing Partner of the DACH region, encompassing Germany, Austria and Switzerland.

Learn more

Awards

Fragomen Professionals Recognized in the 2027 Edition of The Best Lawyers in Mexico™

Eight professionals in Fragomen’s Mexico City office have been recognized in the 2027 edition of The Best Lawyers in Mexico™ for Immigration Law.

Learn more
Fragomen.com home
Select Language
  • English
  • French
  • French - Canadian
  • German

Select Language

  • English
  • French
  • French - Canadian
  • German
ContactCareersMediaClient Portal
Search Fragomen.com
  • Our Services
    For EmployersFor IndividualsBy IndustryCase Studies
  • Our Tech & Innovation
  • Our People
  • Our Insights
    Worldwide Immigration Trends ReportsMagellan SeriesImmigration AlertsEventsMedia MentionsFragomen NewsBlogsPodcasts & Videos
  • Spotlights
    Travel and Mobility Considerations: Situation in the Middle EastNavigating Immigration Under the Second Trump AdministrationImmigration Matters: Your U.S. Compliance RoadmapCenter for Strategy and Applied InsightsView More
  • About Us
    About FragomenOfficesResponsible Business PracticesFirm GovernanceRecognition

Our Services

  • For Employers
  • For Individuals
  • By Industry
  • Case Studies

Our Tech & Innovation

  • Our Approach

Our People

  • Overview / Directory

Our Insights

  • Worldwide Immigration Trends Reports
  • Magellan Series
  • Immigration Alerts
  • Events
  • Media Mentions
  • Fragomen News
  • Blogs
  • Podcasts & Videos

Spotlights

  • Travel and Mobility Considerations: Situation in the Middle East
  • Navigating Immigration Under the Second Trump Administration
  • Immigration Matters: Your U.S. Compliance Roadmap
  • Center for Strategy and Applied Insights
  • View More

About Us

  • About Fragomen
  • Offices
  • Responsible Business Practices
  • Firm Governance
  • Recognition
Select Language
  • English
  • French
  • French - Canadian
  • German

Select Language

  • English
  • French
  • French - Canadian
  • German
ContactCareersMediaClient Portal
Important Updates
Important Updates
November 18, 2026 | VietnamVietnam: Expert Eligibility Expanded, Work Permit Exemptions Revised, Among Other Changes Under New Decree
November 18, 2026 | United StatesForbes: Immigration Rule Aims To Block Many High-Skilled Green Card Applicants
November 18, 2026 | CanadaHuman Resources Director: HR Leaders Must Treat Immigration as Strategy, Not Paperwork
November 18, 2026 | 🌐Middle East - The Latest News on Mobility and Travel Considerations
November 18, 2026 | United StatesPartner Lisa Ryan Appointed to University of San Francisco’s Women in Leadership in the Age of AI Advisory Board
November 18, 2026 | VietnamVietnam: Expert Eligibility Expanded, Work Permit Exemptions Revised, Among Other Changes Under New Decree
November 18, 2026 | United StatesForbes: Immigration Rule Aims To Block Many High-Skilled Green Card Applicants
November 18, 2026 | CanadaHuman Resources Director: HR Leaders Must Treat Immigration as Strategy, Not Paperwork
November 18, 2026 | 🌐Middle East - The Latest News on Mobility and Travel Considerations
November 18, 2026 | United StatesPartner Lisa Ryan Appointed to University of San Francisco’s Women in Leadership in the Age of AI Advisory Board
November 18, 2026 | VietnamVietnam: Expert Eligibility Expanded, Work Permit Exemptions Revised, Among Other Changes Under New Decree
Subscribe

Stay in touch

Subscribe to receive our latest immigration alerts

Subscribe

Our firm

  • About
  • Careers
  • Firm Governance
  • Media Inquiries
  • Recognition

Information

  • Attorney Advertising
  • Legal Notices
  • Privacy Policies
  • AI Transparency Statement
  • UK Regulatory Requirements

Our firm

  • About
  • Careers
  • Firm Governance
  • Media Inquiries
  • Recognition

Information

  • Attorney Advertising
  • Legal Notices
  • Privacy Policies
  • AI Transparency Statement
  • UK Regulatory Requirements

Have a question?

Contact Us
  • LinkedIn
  • Youtube
  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • TikTok
  • Twitter

© 2026 Fragomen, Del Rey, Bernsen & Loewy, LLP, Fragomen Global LLP and affiliates. All Rights Reserved.

Please note that the content made available on this site is not intended for visitors / customers located in the province of Quebec, and the information provided is not applicable to the Quebec market. To access relevant information that applies to the Quebec market, please click here.