• Insights

DHS and DOJ Issue Guidance for Employers Using Electronic I-9 Programs

February 13, 2024

I-9 Programs

Country / Territory

  • United StatesUnited States

Related contacts

Daniel Brown

Daniel Brown

Partner

Washington, DC, United States

Email

[email protected]

T:+1 202 380 1089

Related offices

  • Washington, DC

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Related contacts

Daniel Brown

Daniel Brown

Partner

Washington, DC, United States

Email

[email protected]

T:+1 202 380 1089

Related offices

  • Washington, DC

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Related contacts

Daniel Brown

Daniel Brown

Partner

Washington, DC, United States

Email

[email protected]

T:+1 202 380 1089

Related offices

  • Washington, DC

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

By: Daniel Brown

On December 20, 2023, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and the Immigrant and Employee Rights Section within the Civil Rights Division of the Department of Justice (IER) issued a joint fact sheet for employers using I-9 software programs to complete I-9 forms and access the E-Verify program.

The fact sheet is intended to help employers avoid committing I-9 violations or immigration-related discrimination when they utilize commercially available or proprietary electronic I-9 software programs to complete and retain I-9 forms and access the E-Verify program. 

Employers are Responsible for the Compliance of their Electronic I-9 Systems

ICE first issued regulations in June 2006 authorizing employers to electronically complete, sign and retain I-9 forms. Those regulations contain a number of system standards and requirements as well as several provisions identifying specific system failures that will constitute I-9 violations. 

When conducting I-9 audits, ICE has increasingly been focused on the underlying compliance of any electronic I-9 system the employer is using. We are aware of several cases where ICE has imposed penalties on employers because of compliance failures of the I-9 system being used. 

On page one, the fact sheet makes clear that the responsibility for compliance with ICE regulatory requirements rests with the employer and not the program vendor:

“Using a Form I-9 software program does not guarantee an employer’s compliance with federal law. Employers are responsible for ensuring that any Form I-9 software program used to electronically complete, modify, or retain the Form I-9 or participate in E-Verify complies with all legal requirements.”

It is important that employers don’t simply rely on the fact that an I-9 system is commercially available, but rather that they ensure any prospective I-9 system is compliant with the ICE regulations.

Guidance Regarding Electronic I-9 Systems

Before this fact sheet, the government had issued very little guidance to the public regarding the regulatory requirements for electronic I-9 systems. Unfortunately, the guidance provided in the fact sheet is not comprehensive and it fails to sufficiently address some of the primary compliance requirements within the ICE regulations. The government has still failed to provide employers with practical and useful guidance to enable a review of third-party vendor systems and to conduct sufficient due diligence on their I-9 systems.  

It is also important to note that the fact sheet is a joint product of two different federal agencies with substantially different enforcement interests. Despite these concerns, the fact sheet does provide some insight into the government’s views on certain aspects of the ICE regulatory requirements.

The following are some of the key points from the fact sheet that employers need to be aware of when assessing potential I-9 systems, along with our comments in certain cases:

  • Employees and employers must be allowed to leave optional and unused fields blank when appropriate, such as the Social Security number in section 1 for employers not using E-Verify, and the expiration date field in section 1 next to the “A noncitizen authorized to work” attestation.
      • Comment: The I-9 instructions before the current I-9 form version instructed employers not to leave fields blank but to enter “N/A” instead. This may require I-9 systems to reprogram certain rules for fields where information is not required.
  • Employers must be able to enter any acceptable documentation including receipts, that employees choose to present at either the time of hire or during a re-verification.
  • The I-9 system must comply with the requirements found in the ICE electronic I-9 system regulations, relating to the integrity, accuracy and reliability of the system; security and documentation; indexing; electronic signatures; retention; audit trails; location, retrieval, reading and reproduction abilities; as well as the ability to provide Form I-9 summary files (such as a spreadsheet) containing all the information fields on electronically stored I-9 forms requested by the government during an I-9 audit.
      • Comment: In our view, the government should provide much more comprehensive guidance on these requirements so that employers can better understand what is legally required in practice.
  • The system must allow employees, employers and preparers/translators to make and record corrections to the information entered on the I-9 form.
      • Comment: There are several commercially available I-9 systems that fail to comply with this guidance and lack the functionality to allow corrections of completed I-9 records. In many cases, these systems would instead require the completion of an entirely new I-9 to fix errors.
  • The Form I-9 software program must uniquely identify each person accessing, correcting, or changing an I-9 form.
      • Comment: This is one of the more important requirements within the ICE electronic I-9 regulations. We have seen ICE penalize employers where the government alleges that an I-9 system’s audit trails do not meet this guideline. Unfortunately, the government has failed to provide specific, practical guidance to the public on how to ensure compliance with this requirement.
  • Any I-9 system must not automatically pre-populate the I-9 with employee information that the employer has accessed externally, such as from an employee’s job application.
      • Comment: The government has repeatedly expressed concerns with the pre-population of employee information in section 1 of the I-9 form. Many popular I-9 systems are components of other HRIS systems and are designed to initiate the I-9 form through pre-population of the newly hired employee’s information. Employers should carefully assess whether they want to take on the risk of pre-population given the repeated guidance from the government on this issue.
  • Any I-9 system must not remove any Form I-9 fields, or request more or different information than the I-9 requires.
      • Comment: Many I-9 systems may violate this guidance by adding additional questions seeking information that is not requested by the I-9 form.
  • Any I-9 system must not use auto-correct, use predictive text or post-date a Form I-9.
      • Comment: It would be helpful if the government would provide more detail about what aspects of using auto-correct or predictive text cause concerns. It is not clear what the legal basis is for this prohibition provided in the fact sheet.
  • Any I-9 system must not fail to document any changes made to a form I-9 in an audit trail.
      • Comment: The audit trail requirement is one of the critical regulatory requirements that an I-9 system must comply with. It is important that the I-9 system’s audit trails sufficiently record all of the actions taken on each I-9 record and what individual performed those actions. Many commercially available systems may not meet this requirement.
  • Employers must not change or update an employee’s citizenship or immigration status attestation. The employee must be the one to make changes or corrections to section 1 information.
      • Comment: This is no different from completing an I-9 on paper. The employee must be the one to make any changes or corrections to section 1 information. An I-9 system needs to have the functionality to allow the employee to do this after an I-9 is completed.
  • An I-9 system must not request unnecessary documentation (such as reverifying an employee’s identity or impermissibly reverifying an employee’s permission to work).
      • Comment: An I-9 system should not send notifications that an employee must reverify or provide additional documentation due to the expiration of a List B document or permanent resident card.
  • An I-9 system must not create new E-Verify cases after making corrections to the I-9 form if the employee already received an employment-authorized result.
      • Comment: This can often occur where a system requires the completion of an entirely new I-9 form to correct an error, rather than allowing a correction of the specific information on the existing form.
  • Employers should be cautious of any system claiming government endorsement, certification or approval. DHS does not certify or endorse any I-9 software programs in any way.
  • I-9 systems should not impose unnecessary obstacles that make it harder for employees to start work or get paid, such as when they are waiting to receive a social security number.

Due Diligence and Compliance

Employers should exercise appropriate due diligence when reviewing their existing or prospective electronic I-9 systems.

Compliance with the specific ICE regulatory requirements needs to be incorporated into that due diligence along with other factors such as cost, functionality and interoperability with other systems.

Need to Know More?

For further information and assistance with questions regarding I-9 system requirements and I-9 compliance in general, please contact, Partner Daniel Brown at [email protected].

This blog was published on February 13, 2024, and due to the circumstances, there are frequent changes. To keep up to date with all the latest updates on global immigration, please subscribe to our alerts and follow us on LinkedIn, X, Facebook and Instagram.

Country / Territory

  • United StatesUnited States

Related contacts

Daniel Brown

Daniel Brown

Partner

Washington, DC, United States

Email

[email protected]

T:+1 202 380 1089

Related offices

  • Washington, DC

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Related contacts

Daniel Brown

Daniel Brown

Partner

Washington, DC, United States

Email

[email protected]

T:+1 202 380 1089

Related offices

  • Washington, DC

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Related contacts

Daniel Brown

Daniel Brown

Partner

Washington, DC, United States

Email

[email protected]

T:+1 202 380 1089

Related offices

  • Washington, DC

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Explore more at Fragomen

Blog post

Employment Migration Options for Individuals from Syria with Recognized Protection Status in Germany

Senior Associate Ruben Fiedler explains the employment-based residence options that may be available to individuals from Syria with recognized protection status in Germany and why timing, procedural status and individual circumstances are critical when assessing a potential change in residence basis.

Learn more

Media mentions

Forbes: University Lawsuits Stop Two Trump Immigration Policies

Partner and Executive Director Bo Cooper and Senior Director Leah Rogal authored a letter from Fragomen’s Center for Strategy & Applied Insights addressing the Department of Homeland Security’s interpretation of the curricular practical training regulation.

Learn more

Awards

Fragomen Named Immigration Law Team of the Year at IEL Awards 2026

Fragomen has been named Immigration Law Team of the Year at the International Employment Lawyer Awards 2026, recognizing the firm’s work helping organizations navigate complex immigration and workforce challenges across jurisdictions.

Learn more

Awards

Fragomen Receives Altair’s Star Alliance Innovation Award for WorkReady

Fragomen has received Altair’s Star Alliance Innovation Award in recognition of WorkReady and the solution’s adoption among Altair’s clients.

Learn more

Media mentions

Bloomberg Law: Trump Green Card Proposal Fuels Doubt Over H-1B Worker Pipeline

Partner K. Edward Raleigh discusses how proposed changes to the PERM process could affect US employers’ ability to sponsor foreign workers for permanent residency and retain talent.

Learn more

Media mentions

Forbes: Immigration Rule Aims To Block Many High-Skilled Green Card Applicants

Partner Kevin Miner discusses the legal concerns surrounding the DOL's proposed PERM rule and its potential impact on employers’ ability to retain talent.

Learn more

Blog post

How to Apply for Costa Rica Permanent Residence

In part two of this series, Immigration Supervisor Michael Salas Guzman explains what applicants and families should expect throughout the permanent residence application process, from preparation and filing through final documentation.

Learn more

Media mentions

Human Resources Director: HR Leaders Must Treat Immigration as Strategy, Not Paperwork

Canada Managing Partner Cosmina Morariu outlines how HR leaders can integrate immigration into workforce planning, strengthen business resilience and better manage global mobility risks.

Learn more

Awards

Partner Lisa Ryan Appointed to University of San Francisco’s Women in Leadership in the Age of AI Advisory Board

Partner Lisa Ryan has been appointed to the Advisory Board for the Women in Leadership in the Age of AI Program at the University of San Francisco School of Management.

Learn more

Blog post

Christmas Travel While Your German Residence Permit Is Pending: Do You Need a Fiktionsbescheinigung?

In a new blog, Senior Associate Ruben Fiedler explains what internationally mobile employees and employers should consider before holiday travel, including the importance of checking the legal basis of an interim permit and requesting the appropriate documentation early.

Learn more

Media mentions

Times of India: US Proposes Sweeping Changes to Green Card Rules, Raises Employer Compliance Burden and Tightens Scrutiny of Layoffs

Senior Counsel Mitch Wexler discusses proposed changes to the PERM program, including extended recruitment periods and additional documentation requirements for employers sponsoring foreign workers for permanent residence.

Learn more

Video

Brazil Statutory Director Visa: Requirements, Investment and Process

In this video, Brazil Managing Partner Diana Quintas explains the statutory director visa, outlining who qualifies, key compliance considerations and what employers and directors should consider when planning appointments or changes to board leadership.

Learn more

Blog post

Employment Migration Options for Individuals from Syria with Recognized Protection Status in Germany

Senior Associate Ruben Fiedler explains the employment-based residence options that may be available to individuals from Syria with recognized protection status in Germany and why timing, procedural status and individual circumstances are critical when assessing a potential change in residence basis.

Learn more

Media mentions

Forbes: University Lawsuits Stop Two Trump Immigration Policies

Partner and Executive Director Bo Cooper and Senior Director Leah Rogal authored a letter from Fragomen’s Center for Strategy & Applied Insights addressing the Department of Homeland Security’s interpretation of the curricular practical training regulation.

Learn more

Awards

Fragomen Named Immigration Law Team of the Year at IEL Awards 2026

Fragomen has been named Immigration Law Team of the Year at the International Employment Lawyer Awards 2026, recognizing the firm’s work helping organizations navigate complex immigration and workforce challenges across jurisdictions.

Learn more

Awards

Fragomen Receives Altair’s Star Alliance Innovation Award for WorkReady

Fragomen has received Altair’s Star Alliance Innovation Award in recognition of WorkReady and the solution’s adoption among Altair’s clients.

Learn more

Media mentions

Bloomberg Law: Trump Green Card Proposal Fuels Doubt Over H-1B Worker Pipeline

Partner K. Edward Raleigh discusses how proposed changes to the PERM process could affect US employers’ ability to sponsor foreign workers for permanent residency and retain talent.

Learn more

Media mentions

Forbes: Immigration Rule Aims To Block Many High-Skilled Green Card Applicants

Partner Kevin Miner discusses the legal concerns surrounding the DOL's proposed PERM rule and its potential impact on employers’ ability to retain talent.

Learn more

Blog post

How to Apply for Costa Rica Permanent Residence

In part two of this series, Immigration Supervisor Michael Salas Guzman explains what applicants and families should expect throughout the permanent residence application process, from preparation and filing through final documentation.

Learn more

Media mentions

Human Resources Director: HR Leaders Must Treat Immigration as Strategy, Not Paperwork

Canada Managing Partner Cosmina Morariu outlines how HR leaders can integrate immigration into workforce planning, strengthen business resilience and better manage global mobility risks.

Learn more

Awards

Partner Lisa Ryan Appointed to University of San Francisco’s Women in Leadership in the Age of AI Advisory Board

Partner Lisa Ryan has been appointed to the Advisory Board for the Women in Leadership in the Age of AI Program at the University of San Francisco School of Management.

Learn more

Blog post

Christmas Travel While Your German Residence Permit Is Pending: Do You Need a Fiktionsbescheinigung?

In a new blog, Senior Associate Ruben Fiedler explains what internationally mobile employees and employers should consider before holiday travel, including the importance of checking the legal basis of an interim permit and requesting the appropriate documentation early.

Learn more

Media mentions

Times of India: US Proposes Sweeping Changes to Green Card Rules, Raises Employer Compliance Burden and Tightens Scrutiny of Layoffs

Senior Counsel Mitch Wexler discusses proposed changes to the PERM program, including extended recruitment periods and additional documentation requirements for employers sponsoring foreign workers for permanent residence.

Learn more

Video

Brazil Statutory Director Visa: Requirements, Investment and Process

In this video, Brazil Managing Partner Diana Quintas explains the statutory director visa, outlining who qualifies, key compliance considerations and what employers and directors should consider when planning appointments or changes to board leadership.

Learn more
Fragomen.com home
Select Language
  • English
  • French
  • French - Canadian
  • German

Select Language

  • English
  • French
  • French - Canadian
  • German
ContactCareersMediaClient Portal
Search Fragomen.com
  • Our Services
    For EmployersFor IndividualsBy IndustryCase Studies
  • Our Tech & Innovation
  • Our People
  • Our Insights
    Worldwide Immigration Trends ReportsMagellan SeriesImmigration AlertsEventsMedia MentionsFragomen NewsBlogsPodcasts & Videos
  • Spotlights
    Travel and Mobility Considerations: Situation in the Middle EastNavigating Immigration Under the Second Trump AdministrationImmigration Matters: Your U.S. Compliance RoadmapCenter for Strategy and Applied InsightsView More
  • About Us
    About FragomenOfficesResponsible Business PracticesFirm GovernanceRecognition

Our Services

  • For Employers
  • For Individuals
  • By Industry
  • Case Studies

Our Tech & Innovation

  • Our Approach

Our People

  • Overview / Directory

Our Insights

  • Worldwide Immigration Trends Reports
  • Magellan Series
  • Immigration Alerts
  • Events
  • Media Mentions
  • Fragomen News
  • Blogs
  • Podcasts & Videos

Spotlights

  • Travel and Mobility Considerations: Situation in the Middle East
  • Navigating Immigration Under the Second Trump Administration
  • Immigration Matters: Your U.S. Compliance Roadmap
  • Center for Strategy and Applied Insights
  • View More

About Us

  • About Fragomen
  • Offices
  • Responsible Business Practices
  • Firm Governance
  • Recognition
Select Language
  • English
  • French
  • French - Canadian
  • German

Select Language

  • English
  • French
  • French - Canadian
  • German
ContactCareersMediaClient Portal
Important Updates
Important Updates
November 20, 2026 | MalaysiaMalaysia: New Photograph Verification Processes
November 20, 2026 | United StatesForbes: University Lawsuits Stop Two Trump Immigration Policies
November 20, 2026Fragomen Named Immigration Law Team of the Year at IEL Awards 2026
November 20, 2026Fragomen Receives Altair’s Star Alliance Innovation Award for WorkReady
November 20, 2026 | MalaysiaMalaysia: EXPATS 2.0 Online System to Transition to New System; Application Acceptance Suspension During Transition
November 20, 2026 | MalaysiaMalaysia: New Photograph Verification Processes
November 20, 2026 | United StatesForbes: University Lawsuits Stop Two Trump Immigration Policies
November 20, 2026Fragomen Named Immigration Law Team of the Year at IEL Awards 2026
November 20, 2026Fragomen Receives Altair’s Star Alliance Innovation Award for WorkReady
November 20, 2026 | MalaysiaMalaysia: EXPATS 2.0 Online System to Transition to New System; Application Acceptance Suspension During Transition
November 20, 2026 | MalaysiaMalaysia: New Photograph Verification Processes
Subscribe

Stay in touch

Subscribe to receive our latest immigration alerts

Subscribe

Our firm

  • About
  • Careers
  • Firm Governance
  • Media Inquiries
  • Recognition

Information

  • Attorney Advertising
  • Legal Notices
  • Privacy Policies
  • AI Transparency Statement
  • UK Regulatory Requirements

Our firm

  • About
  • Careers
  • Firm Governance
  • Media Inquiries
  • Recognition

Information

  • Attorney Advertising
  • Legal Notices
  • Privacy Policies
  • AI Transparency Statement
  • UK Regulatory Requirements

Have a question?

Contact Us
  • LinkedIn
  • Youtube
  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • TikTok
  • Twitter

© 2026 Fragomen, Del Rey, Bernsen & Loewy, LLP, Fragomen Global LLP and affiliates. All Rights Reserved.

Please note that the content made available on this site is not intended for visitors / customers located in the province of Quebec, and the information provided is not applicable to the Quebec market. To access relevant information that applies to the Quebec market, please click here.