EU Court of Justice Re-confirms the Possibility to Disregard Certificate of Coverage for Posted Workers
July 18, 2018
Countries / Territories
- 🌐
By: Kristine Zaiceva
The Court of Justice of the European Union (hereafter CJEU) has re-confirmed its position regarding the validity of a Certificate of Coverage also commonly known as a CoC or an A1 certificate. The CJEU has stated that in case the host country has reasonable and concrete doubts regarding the conditions under which the A1 certificate was issued and the country that issued the A1 certificate refuses to reconsider these concerns the courts of the host country may decide to disregard the certificate.
The request for a Certificate of Coverage (commonly known as a CoC, or an A1 certificate amongst the countries that apply the EU Regulations on social security coordination) is fundamental to ensure full compliance with social security obligations for employees that are assigned to work abroad in another EU country on a temporary basis. The A1 certificate indicates in which country social security contributions are being paid and it should be kept available to be presented to the competent institution in the country where the assignee is temporarily working, to confirm the social security position of the employees concerned.
What is interesting about this judgement is that, on the one hand, it emphasizes again, as per consolidated case law, that an A1 certificate is binding to the host country’s authorities, as long as the certificate is not withdrawn by a competent institution of the issuing country.
On the other hand, however, as it also was stated in a recent CJEU decision of last February, that the national courts of the host country may disregard an A1 certificate in case it was issued fraudulently and the issuing institution of the home country is not willing to withdraw it. Please find more details about the recent CJEU decision regarding this particular judgement in one of our previous blogs here.
With the judgment of July 11th, 2018 (case C-356/15), the CJEU has ruled that Belgium infringed the EU Regulations on social security by introducing rules in national legislation that do not meet the principles and requirements of the EU Regulations.
According to current Belgian legislation, where the national court, a public social security institution or a social inspector establishes there has been an abuse in the issuance of an A1 certificate by a given home country, the worker involved should be made subject to Belgian social security legislation.
What is notable about this judgment is that the CJEU has clearly stated that if a host Member State adopts legislation authorizing its own institutions to unilaterally declare an A1 certificate invalid, the principle of sincere cooperation between the competent institutions of the Member States would be jeopardised.
Consequently, the power to make a finding of fraud and to disregard an A1 certificate is limited to the national courts alone, only after the whole procedure of dialogue and conciliation, as laid down in the EU Regulations, has been followed and executed.
The Fragomen Social Security team is prepared to guide clients to optimise their social security programs and reduce related costs. Our strategic approach will help you plan ahead and ensure social security compliance from day one. For any social security related question, please feel free to contact us at [email protected] .
Countries / Territories
- 🌐
Explore more at Fragomen
Podcast
In this episode of The Immigration Conversation, Partner Chad Blocker, Senior Counsel Mitchell Wexler and Associate Alex Kim discuss what prospective EB-5 applicants should know now, including source-of-funds documentation, project selection, concurrent filing, retrogression and upcoming program deadlines.
Blog post
In this blog, Partner Jo Antoons and Senior Manager Marina Ocariz discuss the EU’s provisional agreement on revised social security coordination rules and what employers should know about the expected changes to A1 certificate requirements, posted worker rules and short-term cross-border work compliance.
Blog post
In this blog, Partner Rahul Soni explains the EB-5 grandfathering provisions under the EB-5 Reform and Integrity Act of 2022 and why prospective investors should consider filing before the September 30, 2026 deadline to help preserve statutory protections and reduce exposure to future program uncertainty.
Video
In this video, Practice Leader Kate Praphakornphiphat explains the key requirements, documents, fees and processing time for a Thailand tourist visa, as well as stay duration and extension options for short-term travel.
Fragomen news
Fragomen and Talent Beyond Boundaries announce that they will jointly serve as co-chairs of the Global Task Force on Refugee Labour Mobility for a two-year term beginning in June 2026.
Blog post
In this blog, Manager Gillian Gibbons and Immigration Consultants Gemma Oliver and Larna Kate Hadfield examine how Barnsley’s designation as the UK’s first government-backed Tech Town reflects wider AI and digital growth across the North of England, and why immigration strategy will be critical for employers seeking to access the global talent needed to support regional innovation.
Media mentions
In this Hong Kong Business article, Managing Director Magdalene Tennant discusses Hong Kong’s recent decision to allow employment and dependent visa renewal applications to be filed up to three months before expiry, a change intended to reduce the risk of work disruptions and provide employers with greater flexibility in managing foreign talent.
Media mentions
In this article published by Professional Engineering, Senior Manager Nadine Barnole examines how UK engineering employers can continue to access international talent amid growing skills shortages and a rapidly evolving immigration landscape.
Media mentions
In this Times Brasil CNBC Real Tech interview, Partner Diana Quintas discusses Brazil’s recent visa exemption for Chinese nationals, what it signals for Brazil-China mobility and how technology is helping support more efficient cross-border movement.
Podcast
In this episode of The Immigration Conversation, Business Immigration Manager Ayana Ibrahimi is joined by Lara Dyer, Chief Solutions Officer (Americas) at Talent Beyond Boundaries; Stuart Szabo, CEO and Co-founder of Beacon; and Jessica Turner, Co-founder and CEO of ThriveON, to discuss refugee labour mobility and employment-based pathways for displaced talent.
Video
In this Mobility Minute, Manager Maja Sugui provides an overview of key visa and compliance considerations for business travelers planning trips to China.
Media mentions
In this profile published in Michigan Law’s Law Quadrangle, Counsel Christopher Wendt discusses the role of immigration in supporting the US healthcare workforce and expanding access to civil legal aid in Minnesota.
Podcast
In this episode of The Immigration Conversation, Partner Chad Blocker, Senior Counsel Mitchell Wexler and Associate Alex Kim discuss what prospective EB-5 applicants should know now, including source-of-funds documentation, project selection, concurrent filing, retrogression and upcoming program deadlines.
Blog post
In this blog, Partner Jo Antoons and Senior Manager Marina Ocariz discuss the EU’s provisional agreement on revised social security coordination rules and what employers should know about the expected changes to A1 certificate requirements, posted worker rules and short-term cross-border work compliance.
Blog post
In this blog, Partner Rahul Soni explains the EB-5 grandfathering provisions under the EB-5 Reform and Integrity Act of 2022 and why prospective investors should consider filing before the September 30, 2026 deadline to help preserve statutory protections and reduce exposure to future program uncertainty.
Video
In this video, Practice Leader Kate Praphakornphiphat explains the key requirements, documents, fees and processing time for a Thailand tourist visa, as well as stay duration and extension options for short-term travel.
Fragomen news
Fragomen and Talent Beyond Boundaries announce that they will jointly serve as co-chairs of the Global Task Force on Refugee Labour Mobility for a two-year term beginning in June 2026.
Blog post
In this blog, Manager Gillian Gibbons and Immigration Consultants Gemma Oliver and Larna Kate Hadfield examine how Barnsley’s designation as the UK’s first government-backed Tech Town reflects wider AI and digital growth across the North of England, and why immigration strategy will be critical for employers seeking to access the global talent needed to support regional innovation.
Media mentions
In this Hong Kong Business article, Managing Director Magdalene Tennant discusses Hong Kong’s recent decision to allow employment and dependent visa renewal applications to be filed up to three months before expiry, a change intended to reduce the risk of work disruptions and provide employers with greater flexibility in managing foreign talent.
Media mentions
In this article published by Professional Engineering, Senior Manager Nadine Barnole examines how UK engineering employers can continue to access international talent amid growing skills shortages and a rapidly evolving immigration landscape.
Media mentions
In this Times Brasil CNBC Real Tech interview, Partner Diana Quintas discusses Brazil’s recent visa exemption for Chinese nationals, what it signals for Brazil-China mobility and how technology is helping support more efficient cross-border movement.
Podcast
In this episode of The Immigration Conversation, Business Immigration Manager Ayana Ibrahimi is joined by Lara Dyer, Chief Solutions Officer (Americas) at Talent Beyond Boundaries; Stuart Szabo, CEO and Co-founder of Beacon; and Jessica Turner, Co-founder and CEO of ThriveON, to discuss refugee labour mobility and employment-based pathways for displaced talent.
Video
In this Mobility Minute, Manager Maja Sugui provides an overview of key visa and compliance considerations for business travelers planning trips to China.
Media mentions
In this profile published in Michigan Law’s Law Quadrangle, Counsel Christopher Wendt discusses the role of immigration in supporting the US healthcare workforce and expanding access to civil legal aid in Minnesota.
