Fragomen on Immigration: New Study Reveals Surprising Data on Certain Immigration Appeals
May 6, 2015

Country / Territory
Related contacts

Chairman Emeritus
Related contacts

Chairman Emeritus
Related contacts

Chairman Emeritus
Readers of this blog will likely be no more surprised than we were at the title of a recent article, “Immigration appeals process lacks consistency, fairness, research shows” (posted on, of all places, the phys.org website). Nonetheless, the article’s first sentence prompted us to take a closer look at the underlying study the article summarizes: “The federal immigration appeals process lacks consistency because it reviews a small and skewed sample of cases, according to new Stanford research.” How can this be?
David Hausman, a Ph.D. candidate in political science at Stanford University (who has already been awarded a J.D. by that same institution), undertook a study of cases denied by U.S. immigration judges that were appealed to the Board of Immigration Appeals. After carefully studying a government database he obtained through a request pursuant to the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA), Hausman found that in some immigration courts, the chances that an immigrant will be ordered deported can vary by up to 40 percentage points depending on which immigration judge is randomly assigned to hear the case. Scholarship on appeals and on administrative adjudication would suggest that the appeals process should counteract such disparities, but that is not true in the case of BIA appeals.
Instead, the data indicates that decision-making by the BIA and the federal courts of appeal fails to promote uniformity and consistency in decision-making by immigration judges. In fact, the removal orders of what Hausman terms “harsher” immigration judges—those who order removal up to three times as often as their colleagues—are no more likely to be reversed on appeal, either by the BIA or a federal appeals court, than those of their more generous colleagues.
Hausman concludes that this is because these two appellate bodies actually review an unrepresentative sample of cases. The immigration judges with the higher deportation rates also tend to be impatient by nature, and are more likely to render a decision quickly, before the immigrant has had the chance to find an attorney. Immigrants without lawyers rarely file appeals. More patient judges, by contrast, usually give immigrants much more time to find lawyers.
Accordingly, the BIA reviews (and, in turn, reverses) a disproportionate number of cases decided by more “generous” immigration judges. But the BIA rarely reviews the removal orders of immigrants who might actually have meritorious claims, but who lacked lawyers at the beginning of their proceedings and who appear before harsh, impatient immigration judges.
While there is no similar study of appeals to the Administrative Appeals Office of denials of visa petitions by U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, there may very well be a similar correlation between representation at the petition stage and success on appeal at the AAO.
The complete article will be published in an upcoming issue of the University of Pennsylvania Law Review. It can currently be downloaded from http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2568960.
Country / Territory
Related contacts

Chairman Emeritus
Related contacts

Chairman Emeritus
Related contacts

Chairman Emeritus
Explore more at Fragomen

Video
Immigration Consultant Azela Hadia covers everything you need to know about French citizenship by decree, a legal process through which a foreign national can acquire French nationality.

Blog post
Partner Siobhan Owers and Senior Associate Asif Hanif discuss the latest UK immigration announcements and their impact on the future of care work.

Media mentions
Partner Abeer Al Husseini highlights how Saudi Arabia’s growing film industry is creating jobs, attracting global talent and supporting economic diversification.

Awards
Partner Cindy Jen is recognized as a 2025 “Woman of Influence” by the Silicon Valley Business Journal.

Blog post
This blog highlights the most significant immigration developments shaping Canada and Latin America in 2025. Drawing from Fragomen’s upcoming 2025 Regional Immigration Overviews—available mid-July—it provides actionable insights and strategic guidance to help businesses and individuals navigate the region’s dynamic immigration landscape.

Media mentions
Partner Rachel Beardsley highlights how employment-based immigration supports the US agricultural sector amid labor shortages and evolving policies.

Media mentions
Partner Abeer Al Husseini shares how employers can support mobile talent through travel readiness, immigration awareness and a people-focused approach.

Blog post
Associate Whitney Luman discusses the EB-1C Green Card for multinational managers and executives, exploring non-traditional pathways to permanent residency.

Video
Partner Jack Kim discusses one of many immigration pathways for staying in Canada post-graduation, the Post-Graduation Work Permit (PGWP).

Blog post
Practice Leader Kate Praphakornphiphat, Senior Manager Amy Zhang, Immigration Program Manager Melissa Ngeow and Senior Knowledge Management Specialist Faye Amorado discuss the increasing popularity of highly skilled visas and digital nomad visas in the Asia-Pacific region.

Fragomen news
Partner Cosmina Morariu contributed to Canada’s Semiconductor Council 2025 Talent & Workforce Development report, highlighting immigration’s role in closing talent gaps.

Video
Immigration Consultant Azela Hadia covers everything you need to know about French citizenship by decree, a legal process through which a foreign national can acquire French nationality.

Blog post
Partner Siobhan Owers and Senior Associate Asif Hanif discuss the latest UK immigration announcements and their impact on the future of care work.

Media mentions
Partner Abeer Al Husseini highlights how Saudi Arabia’s growing film industry is creating jobs, attracting global talent and supporting economic diversification.

Awards
Partner Cindy Jen is recognized as a 2025 “Woman of Influence” by the Silicon Valley Business Journal.

Blog post
This blog highlights the most significant immigration developments shaping Canada and Latin America in 2025. Drawing from Fragomen’s upcoming 2025 Regional Immigration Overviews—available mid-July—it provides actionable insights and strategic guidance to help businesses and individuals navigate the region’s dynamic immigration landscape.

Media mentions
Partner Rachel Beardsley highlights how employment-based immigration supports the US agricultural sector amid labor shortages and evolving policies.

Media mentions
Partner Abeer Al Husseini shares how employers can support mobile talent through travel readiness, immigration awareness and a people-focused approach.

Blog post
Associate Whitney Luman discusses the EB-1C Green Card for multinational managers and executives, exploring non-traditional pathways to permanent residency.

Video
Partner Jack Kim discusses one of many immigration pathways for staying in Canada post-graduation, the Post-Graduation Work Permit (PGWP).

Blog post
Practice Leader Kate Praphakornphiphat, Senior Manager Amy Zhang, Immigration Program Manager Melissa Ngeow and Senior Knowledge Management Specialist Faye Amorado discuss the increasing popularity of highly skilled visas and digital nomad visas in the Asia-Pacific region.

Fragomen news
Partner Cosmina Morariu contributed to Canada’s Semiconductor Council 2025 Talent & Workforce Development report, highlighting immigration’s role in closing talent gaps.